(The following does not reflect the

What She Always Wanted

By Razor7826

“I know how I can get him to like you, if that’s what you really want,” said Mary to her younger sister moments after her boyfriend exited the apartment.

“What… what are you talking about?”  Jamie’s face went flush red.  She reached her arms across her chest and pinched her upper arms as she thought of Tim’s built frame and blue eyes.

“You like him don’t you?” asked the older sister, smiling as she egged her younger sister on.

“M… Maybe.”

Mary pushed gently pushed her sister’s shoulder and laughed.  “Come on, admit it.  You think he’s cute, don’t you?”

“I… I guess,” she responded, her face still red with embarrassment.

“Do you or not?”

“Well, does it matter?  He’s your boyfriend.”

“Not necessarily.  You know how it works.”  Mary smiled at her little sister for a brief moment. “Ah, maybe you don’t.  You’re not all that experienced, I guess.”

“Hey!  It’s not my fault my major is all women.”

“You’re impossible, you know that?” said Mary.  “You really need to get out more, unless you want to end up a spinster like Aunt Loretta.”

       “I happen to rather like my life right now,” retorted Jamie, her voice rising in defense.

       “You just keep telling yourself that.”  Mary turned around and walked into the kitchen, her long auburn hair swinging out behind her.  Jamie retreated to her own bedroom and flung herself onto the bed with a bounce.  She slid her arm behind her bed, down the corner of her room, and plucked out her diary.  She unfastened the small latch that kept it locked and opened it to a new page.

       Feb 6th, 1993

       Sis gave me shit again about never having had a boyfriend.  She knows how uncomfortable it makes me feel, so why does she keep doing it?  When she lays into me like that, I regret ever having moved in to her campus apartment.  I’m okay with being left alone… right?  Maybe not.  How does she land guys like Tim? We look almost identical, but why do all the guys flock to her?

       She finished her entry, latched the diary shut, and hid it in the corner before getting ready for bed and falling asleep, dreams of acceptance immersing her soul. 

----------

       Weeks passed, until the day of her twentieth birthday. 

Jamie sat on her bed, wearing her pink pajamas while studying a biology textbook for the next day’s test.  She had just finished the chapter when a knock came on her door.

       “Come in!”

       Mary entered the room.

       “Hey birthday girl,” said Mary.

       “Hi!

       “I have your present for you, but it’s a surprise.”

       “Oh?”

       “Yeah.”  Mary walked over to her sister and crawled onto the bed.  “Let me cover your eyes.”

       “Um… okay.”

       Mary kneeled behind her sister and covered her eyes before saying loudly, “Okay, we’re ready?”

       Jamie heard footsteps enter her room from the hallway.

       “Who’s there?”

       “Surprise,” responded her sister, as she pulled her hands away from Jamie’s eyes.

       A gasp escaped Jamie’s lips as she stared at the naked visage of Mary’s boyfriend Tim in front of her.  “What the hell?”

       “I’m letting you have Tim for the night.”

       “What?” yelled Jamie.

       “Just relax and have fun,” said Mary.  She brushed up against her sister’s back, reached her arms down across Jamie’s shoulders, and put her sister in a hold.  Her long auburn hair dangled in front of Jamie’s eyes.

       “Hey!  Let go of me.”

       “Shhhh… this won’t be very enjoyable as you struggle.  Come on, Tim, you said you’d do it.”

       “Are you sure?” asked Tim, his eyes darting back and forth between the two sisters.

       “Yes, you know how she feels about you,” answered Mary.

       “Mary!  What are you doing?” yelled Jamie.

       “I’m giving you your birthday present, stupid.”

       Tim walked closer, his cock rising in front of him until he stood right in front Jamie, his cock staring her straight on.

       “Let me go!”  Jamie twisted and thrashed, but her sister held her too tightly.

       “Calm down, Jamie.  Calm down.  You’re ready for this.  You can’t be scared of guys forever.”

       “Mary…”

       “Listen.  I read your diary.  I know how scared of sex you are, and I understand where you’re coming from.  But, you can’t let it interfere in your basic ability to interact with guys.  I’m deadly serious when I say I don’t want you to end up like Aunt Loretta.”

       “I keep telling you, I’m alone because I want to be.”

       “Stop rationalizing!  Just let it happen and be done with it, okay?”

       “Please…” cried Jamie, now on the verge of tears.

       Tim backed away and looked toward his girlfriend, then back towards Jamie.  He took another step closer, and Mary leaned back on the bed, pulling her sister back with her.

       Jamie began to relax, accepting what her sister and her boyfriend were going to do to her.  She closed her eyes as Tim crawled first onto the bed, then on top of her.  She felt his hand caress up her left thigh to her pussy, where she was starting to get wet.  His hand pulled away and moved up to her 34C breasts, where it was joined by his other.  He leaned in towards her right nipple and licked around the areola, while twiddling her left with his fingers.  She began to breathe heavily.

       His hand reached down again to her pussy, and, feeling that she was ready, he backed off.

       “Condom?” he asked.

       Mary let go of Jamie’s right shoulder and reached into her pant pocket, from where she pulled a small condom package and handed it to her boyfriend.  He tore open the package with ease and rolled the rubber onto his cock, then kneeled between Jamie’s legs.  He paused for a brief moment before shoving himself into Jamie’s ready cunt.

       She accepted him quietly as he thrust in and out, using her hips for leverage.  Her breaths accelerated in step with his thrusts, the girth of his dick overwhelming her until she came to her first orgasm.  Twitches wracked her body, but her sister and Tim’s weight held her firmly in place.

       Moments later, Tim came as well.  With a heavy sigh, he collapsed on top of Jamie, leaned towards her face, and gave a brief kiss directly on her lips.

It was what she always wanted.

Copyright Razor7826, 2008